Thursday, October 23, 2008

Feminity of Desire


"Man endures pain as an undeserved punishment; woman accepts it as a natural heritage."

I read this line somewhere when I was only 13 years old. The beginning of teen-age, when a child starts thinking and maturing as a grown-up, when a kid is no more a kid and a girl is no more a within-parents' thinking-premises person. She starts developing her own thought process, her own way of observing this world, her own definitions of life, and her own dreams and desires. I developed my own views and outlook then.

I have spent maximum time of initial 13 years of my life with my father and his upbringing influenced me the most and my thinking of course. As a result of frequent transfers in job of my parents, we got to see different places, people and perspectives. My father had different identities at places. The most common was the "father of 3 daughters". I sincerely understand if this doesn't seem understood to most of you, as what's the deal being a father of 3 girls. Even that was my first question to him when he told us about it one day. He had a fellow professor at his college who used to look upon him feeling miserable on his fate of bringing up, taking care and get his 3 daughters married at the end. And that's all a father role has to be for his daughters. When my father refused to agree with him and conferred that his daughters dreams and desires are his sole aim in life...his colleague looked at him as if he was talking something out of this universe. Of course his quick retort can leave anyone shocked and horrified as it is 2008, the 21st century...but then in the 80s it was quite normal. He advised my father not to support and relish his daughters' desires...what if she asks for more?....daughters' desires are a beginning of digging of father's grave...to desire is not what a girl is meant for. My father asked him if he had any daughter and he said he has 3 sons. My father said he would never be able to know what beauty in life is, having a daughter at home...

But papa's colleague's outlook compelled me to mull over my head on it for years. And I am still unanswered. How do we define desire? Isn't it the definition of whatever our heart wishes to do? Is there any line demarcating girl's desire from boy's desire? I wonder sometimes if desire is a feminine term. When heart wishes, it never thinks about whys and hows and whom it belongs to, whether a woman or a man. And today I burn over this concept again. I had visited India this august and was enjoying my stay at home. My younger sister told me about her school friend. I knew her, she was very dear to my sister, and had met her many times during my father's posting at that town. She told me once that she wanted to be a doctor. And I used to tell her that it just needs hard work and determination.

A woman desiring to be something more than a silent order follower is the biggest fear of a father's happy going life...that's what she told me. I asked her about her fear and she said that not all fathers think like mine. I could get her completely and not her father...the man who created her. I asked her to convince her father..and when she said she won't be able to make him understand as he is too adamant to marry her off early and fulfill his responsibility as a father...I said then in that case....be a rebel. And that option was absolutely not on her pages. Where a woman is not allowed to desire for something...will anyone accept her rebellion?

We got transferred from that place but my sister maintained terms with her. I came to know in this visit that she got married at the age of 20 forcefully and this year in August, she had miscarriage.We both were dumbfounded to learn this when my sister called her up. She was just 21 to have her first baby and was suffering from the pain and trauma after her miscarriage. Even my mother had her first child at the age of 25. We learnt from her cousin about this and I was disgusted to know that she was forced to have a baby soon after the marriage. Me and my sister couldn't eat that day after knowing that she is critical after the miscarriage. Doctors saved her of course but not her baby, not her strength, not her desire. A woman who could be a doctor and a life saver ended up being a wife only, being an early mother, being a victim of her family's customs, traditions and wishes. It is not that I am against marriage and children. I want to be a wife and mother someday. But only after I feel when I want to be. I couldn't save her...and I don't know for how many more years I will burn over this issue. We feel so helpless to treat a woman like a person...that's what she is....she is no damn door-mat or wooden chair. She is meant for doing much more than being a man's wife and mother of his children only. Let her desire come out and take a shape...don't kill it ungerminated.

My father says often" If you really want to understand a woman, try standing at her place and think at least once from her outlook, she remains no more complicated and difficult to understand."

12 comments:

Gary Triv said...

Quite touching!!

Gaurav

Gaurav Maroo said...

Hi Miss Purva

i think this one is the most touching and real article so far from ur creative factory....i think the social structure in india even after so many decades of independence remained same in view of WOMEN..they are still having responsibility of feeding family and bringing up children.....

even after so many women leaders and industrialist ...a MAN can never accept her success ,,,its the ego which says that how can a woman do this better than him....that's why still people think that without SON in family there is no strength or respect...

when it comes to fulfilling desires always boys gets preference girls have to sacrifice their desire...that's why the name WOMAN means sacrifice...
i personally feel that a daughter in family is a blessing of God which make Home a heaven together with her mother...

We can never understand the real beauty of universe without touch of a woman...

Regards
Gaurav Maroo
Noida-India

Anonymous said...

Hi Purva,

Its long since i hv been through ur blogs. Though i agree to what you say in general-- importance of woman but you appear a bit female chauvinistic in your tone. Though in past soeity may not have taken a stance from viewpoint of Women but over last couple of decades a lot has changed.

I would say a family's onus lies to a great extent on a women. "Women are sensitive,women are good, they are not jealous as men are and most of the times better than MEN." are some of the phrases which i feel are scrap after seeing many ladies doing what most of the men could not ever do.

Even soon after Indian supreme court's decision tht women can have a say in property men so called sensible and sensitive women's have filed tons of cases on their brothers etc. The imp point to note is these women's were no where in picture when their old parents/ brothers needed them.

Its not that Men dont want his better part come out of peeling potatoes in kitchen but men need women to perform roles of mothers. I agree some women are forced to have early marriage/kids which is wrong but what to say of a lady in 25-35 age limit ("best age to have kids" John Hopkins Hospital's release) a who dont want to have kids for sake of their career prospectus. Those ladies are diverging from the nature's dictum.

Not only this I personally know many people (even you know some) who have been ditched by their female friends (who in look for greener pastures of wealth etc left their betterhalves) -- so where the Sensitivity in Women has Gone?

In this world there is equal importance of both the genders--- ask those innumerable girls who dont have brothers ( who look for brothers on Rakhi, or if they are in some trouble they ask god that why they have not been blessed by a brother).

Without indulging much ito these arguments I would say that Men are as important and integral part of society as Women are. The society needs Men & Women who sagacious enough to diffrentiate their liberties from responsibilities.

We cant feel beauty of nature without touch of women & We cant explore nature without touch of a Men.

Regards,
Abhishek shekhawat

Anonymous said...

Hi Purva,

Its long since i hv been through ur blogs. Though I agree to what you say in general-- importance of woman but you appear a bit female chauvinistic in your tone. Though in past society may not have taken a stance from viewpoint of Women but over last couple of decades a lot has changed.

"People say a family's onus lies to a great extent on a women. Women are sensitive,women are good, they are not jealous as men are and most of the times better than MEN." are some of the phrases which I feel are scrap after seeing many ladies doing what most of the men could not ever imagine to do.

soon after Indian supreme court's decision tht women can have a say in property of father so called sensible and sensitive women's have filed tons of cases on their brothers etc asking for right in property. The imp point to note is these women's were no where in picture when their old parents/ brothers needed them.

Its not that Men dont want his better part come out of peeling potatoes in kitchen but what pintches is to see women running from roles which nature has made them for. I agree some women are forced to have early marriage/kids which is wrong but what to say of a lady in 25-35 age limit ("best age to have kids" John Hopkins Hospital's release) a who dont want to have kids for sake of their career prospectus. Arent these ladies diverging from the nature's dictum.

Not only this I personally know many people (even you know some) who have been ditched by their girlfriends/wives--who in search for greener pastures of wealth etc left their betterhalves -- so where the Sensitivity in Women has Gone?

In this world there is equal importance of both the genders--- ask those innumerable girls who dont have brothers ( who look for brothers on Rakhi, or if they are in some trouble they ask god that why they have not been blessed by a brother).

Without indulging much ito these arguments ( as my midterms are going on) I would say that Men are as important and integral part of society as Women are. The society needs Men & Women who are sagacious enough to diffrentiate their liberties from responsibilities.

We cant feel beauty of nature without touch of women & We cant explore nature without touch of a Men.

Regards,
Abhishek shekhawat

Yogesh said...

Abhishek, I think Purva has an innocent concern about women’s desire. Please lets not make it as war between women and men. I agree with you that both men and women are equally important to society. In India, people are changing their attitude towards women or rather towards women “mind”. People are thinking about women’s desire and their feeling. However this is observed in some part of society; we need everybody follow this.

Purva, now about your concern. As a liberal human being I am also concerned about this. I have also seen many weird examples like sending boy in convent school and girl in vernacular medium school. Also promoting only boys to take higher education and so on. There are plenty of such examples. But my question is does only father (man) do this? No, a mother (women) equally participates in such discrimination. Who wants a baby boy the most? a grandmother (a women). I am sad when I see women being biased towards boys.

I really don’t want to blame anybody, either man or women. This is nobody’s fault. This is fault of our (indian) mentality. All parents are optimistic so they believe that their son will take their care in old age. That’s why parent tend to nurture boys more than girls. They feel that why to invest on girl if she is going to marry someone and go away. No father or mother could discriminate between boys and girls from their heart. Nobody would want setback women from her desire. This is only the situation that’s make them do this. I believe that little more awareness would help to change the situation.

Regards,
Yogesh

Purva said...

@Gaurav-Thanks friend...You are right.We can't feel the beauty of universe without touch of a woman.Life seems incomplete without mother,sister,wife and daughter.

Purva said...

@Abhishek-I completely understand your say of men and women are integral part of society and I am not denying the importance of man.I don't deny that even women at times are proven insensitive and cruel.But what I covered in this post was just a small story which forced me to look at myself and others a different way.I accept that there must be various examples around who can be placed under the category of insensitive women. But I wanted to conclude that be it man or woman,they should be let to make the decisions of their own lives. Freedom is our birthright, whether it is a man or a woman.

Purva said...

@Yogesh-I got what you wish to say.I have also seen examples of women in society where a grandmother wishes to disown a female child and gives merits on having a male child to take their lineage forward.I know that a father and mother can never discriminate amongst their children. Infact,I trust the relationship with parents more than any other truth in this world. But I have also seen lives shattering and desires tearing apart.And this story was only one of them. I agree with Abhishek that I might have sounded like a female chauvinistic in this post but I was writing about the feminity of desire.I may also write something about male desire later.My whole concern was not to malign or vilify all males existing in our society. I just wanted to draw peoples' attention to a small yet important feature of women's life;her desire to make her identity. If it can be taken care of, then I truly believe that a woman feels happiest person on earth being a mother.

Anonymous said...

well....grandmother disowning a feamle child.......either this is 1960--1970 going on Or we are talking about some village in sindh provine in Pakistan

...

Abhishek

Unknown said...

Abishek, I think either its been long that you have touched any Indian newspaper or you may be residing in a different country.
Here, still the newspapers are full of girls being burned in demand for dowry,aborting female feuteus , killing of infant girl child,teenage girls are killed for "family honor" ( See times of india , delhi edition, 7th nov 2008)
and I think girl is a girl even if it is US, India or in a "some village in sindh provine in Pakistan".
AND,
grandmother still disown a feamle child. Talk to any ( most) grandmother and you will know the answer.

~
Harsh

Purva said...

@Abhishek- It is neither 1960-1970 going on nor we are talking about village in sindh province in Pakistan. It is very much in our own country and in the place we have lived and have been with the people so far. Despite touching horizons and achieving a lot in life,there are few women still living a harsh life in society. I am not talking about females living in metro. But if you go to the remote places or any villages in our own state, you will find the example of grandmother pressurizing her daughter-in-law and son to disown their female child. I have seen such examples in front of my eyes. Again, I was just talking about one aspect of woman's life.

Purva said...

@Harsh--Yes, I agree with you.Infact, what boils me so much is the newspaper publishing such examples every day.It is very sad to know that woman is still not safe in the society. I keep myself on their places and imagine as how it would be living a your own life on condition put by others. Sometimes I feel my degree, higher studies and high status in society is of no use when I can't help such sufferers around me.